How Can You Avoid Adding Visual Artifacts When Sharpening Your Images?

May 9, 2022

Are you adding RGB artifacts into images when sharpening? How is Midtone Detail different (in DaVinci Resolve)? Plus, sharpening in LAB space.


Series

Texture Management Part 2: Selectively Using Sharpen, Midtone Detail, and LAB (using DaVinci Resolve)

In my previous Insight in this series, you learned about the concept of texture control & management.

In Part 2 of this series we start talking about node based color management and working on the L channel of the Lab color space. Our goal is to overcome the color artifacts created by RGB sharpening (a type of chromatic abberation).

Digging Deeper on L*a*b

Though briefly mentioned in this video, this is a point worth elaborating upon: Sharpening and manipulating textures on the L channel is a well established practice coming from still photography practices and dating back to the late 90’s-early 2000’s. Dan Margulis’s 2005 influential book “Photoshop LAB Color: The Canyon Conundrum and Other Adventures in the Most Powerful Colorspace”  (try to find a first edition 😉 ) helped entrench this technique.

Lab is an interesting color space – also known as CIELAB or L*a*b. It’s a perceptual color space (mimicking our visual system) and its gamut matches the entire gamut of human photopic (daylight) vision.

Here’s how Wikipedia describes Lab’s L channel:

‘L’ is calculated using the cube root of the relative luminance with an offset near black. This results in an effective power curve with an exponent of approximately 0.43 which represents the human eye’s response to light under daylight (photopic) conditions.

Lab’s two color channels A (Red Green) and B (Blue Yellow) are based on the opponent color model of human vision and represent the 4 perceptual “Pure Hues”. Lab’s design gives it advantages in image manipulation that can be leveraged in countless workflows, not just texture work.

Why the L channel and why Lab? Why not the V channel in HSV (or L in HSL)?

This is a long answer that will be elaborated more upon as the series continues.  Lets just say for now that:

  1. Lab generates particularly better results in darker areas of the image
  2. V or L channels from HSV/HSL produce some (irregular) color artifacts in the blacks
  3. V or L channels from HSV/HSL are not representative of the human visual system response like the L from lab – (or the Y from YUV). Lab treats values differently, and tends to repeatedly produce better looking results, especially when pushing it to the more extreme adjustments.

We will dive deeper into all these concepts as this series progresses. You will learn how Lab’s especially handy when we start constructing our oun node trees and tools.

In this Insight

We are puting the Sharpen and Midtone Detail tools to work, seeing what they do and how you can use them with actual images. This Insight starts with the basic Sharpen tool and compares it to the popular Midtone Detail slider (found on both the Primaries and HDR palettes). Then, we compare both operations to performing them on the L channel in LAB colorspace.

Learning Goals

  1. The Sharpen palette and how the Coring and Level operations refine its operations
  2. The artifacts caused by the “Level” slider in the sharpen tab and how to deal with it
  3. Executing Luminance-based sharpening by using Lab in the sharpening node
  4. Examining the Midtone Detail slider, how it sharpens, and how it differs from the Sharpen palette

Related Mixing Light Insights

  • Series: LAB Fundamentals – Patrick’s early series on using LAB when this colorspace was released as an option in DaVinci Resolve 12.

– Hector

Member Content

Sorry... the rest of this content is for members only. You'll need to login or sign up to continue (we hope you do!).

Membership options
Member Login

Comments

Homepage Forums How Can You Avoid Adding Visual Artifacts When Sharpening Your Images?

Viewing 3 reply threads

    • Jim Robinson
      Participant

      Really interesting Hector.
      I was not aware of how much color pollution was being added during the sharpening process. I think I may have instinctively thought that though. I often retain my sharpening to within a power window selection as to not screw up the rest of the image that I don’t want sharpened. The LAB color space is now going to be my “go to” for adding sharpening.

      Thanks a lot- looking forward to the next one. Cheers


    • Pourang
      Participant

      Thank you.


    • Willian Aleman
      Participant

      Hector – Great insight. Thank you!


    • François Dompierre
      Participant

      Thanks Hector! Can we use LAB in a colour managed pipeline? ACES or RCM2


      • Hector Berrebi
        Participant

        Hey François.

        Yup. The Alexa clip I demonstrated was in RCM2

        and no problem using the same techniques in ACES as well

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Hundreds of Free Tutorials

Get full access to our entire library of 900+ color tutorials for an entire week!


Start Your Free Trial
Loading...