Tech Vs Art

The Art Of Color Grading : Tech Versus Art

September 9, 2015

Color grading is a balance between technical knowledge and creative vision. Dan explores the issue of tech versus art colorists face today.


Series

The Art Of Color Grading : Tech Versus Art

This Insight has been inspired by a great tweet I read from master colorist Dave Hussey.

Screen Shot 2015-09-09 at 20.44.06

It’s something I have spoken about here before on Mixing Light and it’s a topic quite close to my heart

I’d like to kick off a series based on how we look at and market ourselves as colorists.

A lot of colorists focus on being the ultimate geek and focusing on the technicality of color grading – monitors, LUTs, calibration, color space math etc.  It’s not that these things are important to being a proficent colorist but there is the deal:

Color grading is a Creative job.

Colorists like Dave Hussey, Aidan Farrell and countless others have battled for years and years to shake the stereotype of colorists being geeky engineers.

The geek and technology side of our job is just a bi-product of what we need to know to achieve our creative result. In other words, knowing the precise XY coordinates of a particular hue on a CIE 1931 diagram is great, but does the shot you’re working on actually look good?

As colorists, we take footage from the real-world and add the final touch of magic that along with lens choice and lighting and countless other decisions in the image making process, takes us away from our cinema seat or living room and into the story.

That’s what being a colorist is all about – enhancing story.

Pat and Robbie and I have said several times in MailBag episodes all that matters is what’s on screen, and audience doesn’t care about your amazing secondary curve technique processed through 27 inverse linear LUTs!

Think about your favourite film, commercial or music video – Colorists and color timers have helped create some amazing universes – and it doesn’t really matter the tool or technique they used – what matters is the result and how their creative vision for the project was realized.

 

The happy greener than green world of Hobbiton in Lord Of The Rings
YouTube video

The hostile world of Omaha Beach in Saving Private Ryan
YouTube video

Even the teal and orange world of Hollywood.
YouTube video

A worrying trend in the world of color grading is that people see our job as ‘apply the magical LUT’ that makes it all look amazing and then make sure nothing is blown out or crushed and then hit render.

This attitude ignores how a colorist has learned to see light and color, shape it, bend it, and make it more pleasing.  Not in a 1’s and 0’s sort of way but it a real creative artistic way.

I think a great quote that sums up how our industry is starting to look is from the legendary John Lasseter from Pixar :

‘I remember one guy, who worked with a computer graphics company, coming up to me after a screening to ask what software I used to get the humor in!’

As a colorist, I try and pitch myself as an artist, a part of the process that has as much creativity and adds as much to a project as the editor or composer on a project.

Member Content

Sorry... the rest of this content is for members only. You'll need to login or sign up to continue (we hope you do!).

Membership options
Member Login

Comments

Homepage Forums The Art Of Color Grading : Tech Versus Art

  • This topic has 16 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 7 years ago by Toby Tomkins.
Viewing 7 reply threads

    • Jason Bowdach
      Participant

      Pure gold! Couldnt have asked for a better discussion


    • Marc Wielage
      Participant

      Then again, I can recall a great line from a famous LA commercial colorist I knew casually in the 1990s, who said, “I don’t want to be the best colorist in LA… I want to be the best PAID colorist in LA.” The lines between art and commerce are also a factor.


    • DanDiaz
      Guest

      I had a feeling there was going to be an insight when i read that tweet. Great post Dan, took a lot from this one.


    • Dan Moran
      Participant

      You guys know me so well 🙂


    • Dan Moran
      Participant

      Amen to that man! I think I slightly feel the same!!


    • Dan Moran
      Participant

      It’s a tricky one I find. We need to know the tech but some of our clients want a modern version of the master painter Da Vinci 🙂


    • Jason Bowdach
      Participant

      Its a breath of fresh air to hear, as I spend so much time dealing w technical issues but my true satisfaction lies in the creative work. As I do conform, color, online, and occasionally a “VFX-like” fixes or so, its great to think of exactly WHAT type of work i want to do for career goals. Looking forward to future insights on this topic


    • Toby Tomkins
      Guest

      All good points. I think it’s just like any art or profession, whereby the knowledge of the medium, tools and history simply forms a better understanding of the subject, which allows for an efficient approach to finding a solution or creative goal.

      The technology will always be a means to an end, but I’d also argue that a better understanding of the means can get you to the end quicker.

      “An artist must have his measuring tools not in the hand, but in the eye” – Michelangelo

      But I must admit I love my scopes (-;

      Great insight.

Viewing 7 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Hundreds of Free Tutorials

Get full access to our entire library of 900+ color tutorials for an entire week!


Start Your Free Trial
Loading...